Shorting US Stocks Above RSI 70|Daily Backtest of 3 Exits
Shorting the day after RSI(14) crosses above 70: ENTRIQ backtest of 100 US stocks on daily charts (5–56 years each), 3 exits, by trend, volatility and earnings.
What this backtest of selling above RSI 70 examines
These are the results of backtesting 100 stocks in ENTRIQ (5 to 56 years of data depending on the stock) (Dataset v1.0).
RSI is an oscillator that measures, on a scale of 0 to 100, how overheated the market is. A reading of 70 or above is generally seen as a sign of an "overbought" market, and it is sometimes used as grounds for selling (short selling) in anticipation of a pullback. However, "overbought" does not mean "about to fall right away." In a strong uptrend, RSI can stay above 70 for a long time.
This article looks at how prices actually moved after a short sale entered at the open on the next trading day after RSI(14) crossed above 70. A short sale is a trade that gains as the share price falls and loses as it rises. Also, because there is no theoretical limit to how far a share price can rise, the loss on a single trade can exceed -100% (a largest loss below -100% is not a calculation error). This is an observation of historical data, not investment advice. ENTRIQ's chart replay lets you record and practice entries from the sell side (short selling) as well as the buy side.
The backtest of buying when RSI drops below 30 is covered in Daily RSI Below 30 on US Stocks|Backtest of 3 Exits. For the basics of RSI, see What Is RSI|Meaning, Reading and Formula for Beginners and Complete Guide to RSI|Reading, Settings, Entries and Testing.
Test conditions
- Universe: 100 US stocks selected from the current S&P 500 constituents, taking the largest by market cap with up to 15 stocks per sector
- Period: The full history available for each stock (5 to 56 years depending on the stock)
- Timeframe: Daily (split-adjusted)
- RSI setting: Period 14, Wilder's smoothing
- Entry: Sell short at the open on the next trading day after RSI(14) crosses above 70
- Overlapping positions: New signals in the same stock while a position is open are skipped (only one position at a time)
Exit pattern definitions
- Pattern A (A_signal): Buy to cover at the open on the next trading day after RSI falls below 50 (if it doesn't, buy to cover at the close on the 60th trading day). No stop loss
- Pattern B (B_10bars): Buy to cover at the close on the 10th trading day after entry. No stop loss
- Pattern C (C_stop5): Stop loss (buy to cover) if the share price rises 5% above the entry price. If the stop isn't hit, buy to cover at the close on the 10th trading day. If the stock gaps up at the open, the fill is at that open price, so a single trade's loss can exceed -5%
About survivorship bias
This test uses the current constituents of the S&P 500. Stocks that were delisted or removed from the index in the past are not included, so the results may be skewed in a more favorable direction than actual trading results. Keep this in mind when reading the figures.
Overall results (comparing the 3 patterns)
| Metric | A_signal | B_10bars | C_stop5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sample size (N) | 8,404 | 12,783 | 13,816 |
| Share of trades closed in profit | 59.7% | 46.7% | 42.7% |
| Average P/L | -1.09% | -0.41% | -0.37% |
| Average gain (trades closed in profit) | +4.50% | +3.94% | +4.00% |
| Average loss (trades closed at a loss) | -9.55% | -4.32% | -3.68% |
| Profit factor | 0.71 | 0.82 | 0.82 |
| Largest loss | -275.8% | -118.0% | -39.8% |
| Median MAE (maximum adverse excursion) | -5.06% | -3.09% | -3.16% |
| Longest losing streak (per stock) | 10 | 14 | 19 |
| Average holding period | 23.5 trading days | 10.0 trading days | 8.5 trading days |
Note: Past sample (N=8,404, N=12,783, N=13,816); not indicative of future results.
What the comparison between patterns shows
Sample size ranked pattern C > pattern B > pattern A, and the average holding period ranked pattern A > pattern B > pattern C. Because pattern A keeps holding until RSI falls below 50, its average holding period of 23.5 trading days was the longest.
The share of trades closed in profit ranked pattern A > pattern B > pattern C, with pattern A the highest. Average P/L, on the other hand, ranked pattern C > pattern B > pattern A, with pattern A the lowest.
This contrast reflects how pattern A is built: it closes in profit more often, but because it keeps holding without a stop loss, losses on trades closed at a loss are larger. In fact, the average loss (trades closed at a loss) was larger (more negative) in pattern A, then pattern B, then pattern C, and the largest loss followed the same ranking. Pattern A's largest loss of -275.8% fell far below -100%, and the theoretically unlimited loss risk specific to short selling shows up in the figures.
For profit factor, B and C were both 0.82 and A was the lowest (0.71); all were below 1, and an overall tendency for losses to outweigh gains was observed.
Results by trend
RSI crossing above 70 during an uptrend (the close is above SMA200, and SMA200 is higher than it was 20 trading days earlier) is the regime with the largest sample size.
Pattern A (held until RSI falls below 50)
| Trend | N | Share of trades closed in profit | Average P/L | Profit factor | Median MAE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Uptrend | 5,926 | 59.4% | -1.12% | 0.69 | -4.86% |
| Downtrend | 641 | 64.1% | -0.72% | 0.84 | -5.47% |
| Range | 1,631 | 59.7% | -0.75% | 0.79 | -5.49% |
Note: Past sample (N=5,926, N=641, N=1,631); not indicative of future results.
In pattern A, the share of trades closed in profit, average P/L and profit factor were all highest in downtrends, then ranges, then uptrends. The median MAE (maximum adverse excursion) was larger (more negative) in ranges, then downtrends, then uptrends. When positions were held without a stop loss, the overall results were the weakest in uptrends.
Patterns B and C (fixed short holding period; C includes a stop loss)
In patterns B and C as well, the share of trades closed in profit, average P/L and profit factor ranked downtrend > uptrend > range. Both patterns share the tendency for downtrends to show the best results and ranges the weakest.
Sample sizes during uptrends were large in both pattern B (9,691 trades) and pattern C (10,422 trades), showing that most RSI crosses above 70 occurred during uptrends. Pattern B's median MAE was larger (more negative) in downtrends, then ranges, then uptrends, and pattern C's median MAE followed the same ranking of downtrend > range > uptrend.
Results by volatility
High volatility is defined as ATR(14) divided by the close being in the top 20% over the stock's full history, and low volatility as being in the bottom 20%.
Pattern A
| Volatility bucket | N | Share of trades closed in profit | Average P/L | Profit factor | Median MAE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| High volatility | 799 | 63.8% | -0.81% | 0.85 | -7.45% |
| Normal | 5,350 | 59.8% | -1.08% | 0.72 | -5.28% |
| Low volatility | 2,255 | 58.1% | -1.22% | 0.60 | -4.02% |
Note: Past sample (N=799, N=5,350, N=2,255); not indicative of future results.
In pattern A, the share of trades closed in profit, average P/L and profit factor were all highest in high volatility, then normal, then low volatility. However, the median MAE (maximum adverse excursion) was also larger (more negative) in high volatility, then normal, then low volatility, and the average loss (trades closed at a loss) followed the same ranking. This may be because prices tend to move more in both directions in high-volatility periods, so gains were larger when trades closed in profit, while adverse moves were also larger when no stop loss was used.
In patterns B and C as well, average P/L and profit factor were highest in high volatility, then normal, then low volatility. Pattern C's largest loss was largest in the normal bucket, then low volatility, then high volatility, which may suggest that in high-volatility periods the 5% stop loss was triggered earlier and helped keep the largest loss down.
Results near and away from earnings (2008 onward)
The 5 trading days before and after an earnings date are defined as "near earnings," and all other periods as "away from earnings" (earnings date data is only available from 2008 onward, so this classification covers only samples from 2008 onward).
Pattern A (by earnings)
| Distance from earnings | N | Share of trades closed in profit | Average P/L | Profit factor | Median MAE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Away from earnings | 2,588 | 57.8% | -1.47% | 0.61 | -5.01% |
| Near earnings | 1,039 | 56.4% | -1.29% | 0.64 | -4.98% |
Note: Past sample (N=2,588, N=1,039); not indicative of future results.
In pattern A, the share of trades closed in profit was higher away from earnings, while average P/L and profit factor were higher near earnings. The largest loss and the median MAE were both larger (more negative) away from earnings, indicating that the away-from-earnings group includes cases where deep adverse moves occurred while positions were held for a long time without a stop loss.
In patterns B and C, the share of trades closed in profit was higher near earnings in both cases. Pattern B's average P/L and profit factor were higher away from earnings, while in pattern C they were higher near earnings. It is an interesting observation that the relationship with earnings changes depending on the exit method. For more on backtesting around earnings, see also Backtesting US Stock Earnings|Using ENTRIQ Earnings Markers.
When losses grow on short sales during uptrends
Across this backtest, short sales after RSI crossed above 70 were especially weak in periods when a strong uptrend continued.
In pattern A, the largest loss during uptrends was -275.8%, far below -100%. Because positions were held without a stop loss, this includes trades whose losses piled up while the share price kept rising for a long time. In pattern B, the largest loss during uptrends was also large at -80.7%, so there were cases of large adverse moves even with a fixed 10-trading-day holding period.
With its 5% stop loss, pattern C kept the largest loss during uptrends to -22.2%. However, the number of times the stop is hit (that is, trades closed at a loss) increases, so narrowing the maximum loss per trade always needs to be checked together with the balance of the share of trades closed in profit and average P/L.
Limitations and caveats
- Survivorship bias: Only the current S&P 500 constituents are covered. Stocks that went bankrupt or were delisted in the past are not included, so the results may be skewed in a more favorable direction than the market as a whole.
- Slippage and commissions: Real trades incur trading costs, but they are not included in this backtest.
- Costs of short selling: Short selling can involve costs such as stock borrow fees. These are not included in this backtest.
- Single-condition test: Only the condition of RSI(14) crossing above 70 is examined. Results may change when other conditions are combined.
- Uneven periods: The test period varies from 5 to 56 years depending on the stock. Stocks with longer histories have a greater influence on the results.
With ENTRIQ's Chart Replay, you can practice checking these conditions yourself on actual charts. And with Strategy Tags, you can build up and compare the results of your own trades by condition.
Summary
This article examined a backtest of short sales entered on the next trading day after RSI(14) crossed above 70, using 3 exit patterns.
- Overall profit factor was below 1 in every pattern, and as a single condition, a tendency for losses to outweigh gains was observed
- Pattern A had the highest share of trades closed in profit, but because it keeps holding without a stop loss, its losses on trades closed at a loss and its largest loss were the largest
- By trend, downtrends had the highest profit factor in all patterns. Uptrends showed the weakest results in pattern A, and ranges showed the weakest results in patterns B and C
- High-volatility periods had relatively higher average P/L and profit factor, but adverse moves (median MAE) were also larger
- Pattern C's 5% stop loss was seen to limit the largest loss per trade, but its share of trades closed in profit was the lowest
These are strictly observations of historical data. Use ENTRIQ's chart replay to test the same conditions yourself on the stocks and historical period you choose.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
Q. If I short when RSI goes above 70, will the price pull back? A. In this backtest, profit factor was below 1 in all patterns. RSI above 70 is often used as a sign of an overbought market, but in a strong uptrend RSI can stay above 70 for a long time, and these results suggest caution when interpreting a single condition.
Q. What is the difference between no stop loss (pattern A) and a stop loss (pattern C)? A. Pattern A keeps holding without a stop loss until RSI falls below 50. Its share of trades closed in profit is higher, but losses on trades closed at a loss are larger, and its largest loss was also the deepest. Pattern C uses a 5% stop loss, so the loss per trade is kept down, but its share of trades closed in profit was the lowest.
Q. Why were the results for short sales during uptrends weak? A. One possible reason is that an uptrend is a state in which buying momentum continues; in the data, many cases were observed where the share price kept rising even after a short sale above RSI 70. Especially when positions are held without a stop loss, as in pattern A, adverse moves tend to be prolonged.
Q. Can I apply these results directly to my own trading? A. This backtest examines historical data for a specific group of stocks under specific conditions. Results change when the stocks, period or timeframe change. We recommend retesting with your own stocks and conditions in ENTRIQ.
Q. Can I practice selling (short selling) in ENTRIQ? A. Yes. ENTRIQ's chart replay lets you record and practice entries from the sell side (short selling) as well as the buy side.
Related articles
- Complete Guide to RSI|Reading, Settings, Entries and Testing
- Daily RSI Below 30 on US Stocks|Backtest of 3 Exits
- Daily RSI Backtest on US Stocks by Trend|How Results Vary
- Daily RSI Below 30 on US Stocks|Results by Volatility Bucket
This article is provided for informational purposes to examine and organize historical data and does not recommend any specific trade. The figures shown are past samples and do not indicate future results. All investment decisions are your own responsibility.
Test the same condition used in this article on symbols of your choice.
Backtest this conditionReproduce this validation yourself
With ENTRIQ's chart replay, you can trade through past charts using the same rules.
Try the demo — no sign-upNo sign-up or card needed. Runs right in your browser. Start 14-day free trial →
Validate your method on past charts
The same validation in this article can be reproduced with your own method. On past charts, do the classics really work?
- ✓ Replay past charts
- ✓ AI feedback on your trades
- ✓ Validate methods with statistics
No sign-up or card needed. Runs right in your browser.