ENTRIQ|Lab
Try ENTRIQ
StrategyLAYER 1

Daily RSI Below 30 in Downtrends on US Stocks|Key Pitfalls

What follows an RSI-below-30 buy in a downtrend? An ENTRIQ backtest of 100 US stocks on daily charts (5–56 years each), compared with uptrends and ranges.

About this article

These are the results of backtesting 100 stocks in ENTRIQ (5 to 56 years of data depending on the stock) (Dataset v2.0). The universe is US stocks selected from the current S&P 500 constituents, and this article looks at the characteristics of buying when RSI drops below 30 during a downtrend, based on the idea that "oversold = bounce."

The overall picture by market regime (integrated data including the comparison with ranges and uptrends) is covered in Daily RSI Below 30 on US Stocks|Backtest of 3 Exits. This article takes only the "downtrend" phases from that data and examines them in more depth.


Test conditions

Entry and exit patterns

  • Universe: 100 US stocks selected from the current S&P 500 constituents, taking the largest by market cap with up to 15 stocks per sector
  • Period: The full history available for each stock (only stocks with at least 5 years of data), from 1970 to 2026
  • Timeframe: Daily (split-adjusted)
  • RSI setting: Period 14 (Wilder's smoothing, the same calculation as ENTRIQ's charts)
  • Entry: Buy at the open on the next trading day after RSI(14) crosses below 30. New signals in the same stock while a position is open are skipped (only one position at a time)
  • Market regime (downtrend): The close is below SMA200, and SMA200 is lower than it was 20 trading days earlier

The exits were compared across 3 patterns.

  • Pattern A (rsi50): Exit at the open on the next trading day after RSI returns to 50 or above (if it doesn't, exit at the close on the 60th trading day). No stop loss
  • Pattern B (10bars): Exit at the close on the 10th trading day after entry. No stop loss
  • Pattern C (stop5): Stop loss at -5%. If the stop isn't hit, exit at the close on the 10th trading day. If the stock gaps down at the open, the fill is at that open price, so a single trade's loss can exceed -5%

About survivorship bias

This test uses the current S&P 500 constituents. Stocks that were delisted or removed from the index in the past are not included. This may make the backtest results look more favorable than they would if those stocks were included (survivorship bias). Please read the figures as reference values.


Results: RSI below 30 during downtrends

The 3 patterns side by side

The table below shows the results when limited to drops below RSI 30 during downtrends.

MetricPattern A (rsi50)Pattern B (10bars)Pattern C (stop5)
Sample size (N)1,9063,0143,464
Share of trades closed in profit70.5%53.8%42.0%
Average P/L+2.04%+1.17%+0.46%
Average gain (trades closed in profit)+7.12%+7.13%+7.22%
Average loss (trades closed at a loss)-10.32%-5.91%-4.49%
Profit factor1.691.441.18
Largest loss (single trade)-93.3%-72.5%-32.3%
Longest losing streak (per stock)61215
Median MAE (maximum adverse excursion)-5.42%-4.12%-4.27%
Average holding period19.7 trading days10.0 trading days7.3 trading days

Note: Past sample (N=1,906, N=3,014, N=3,464); not indicative of future results.


Comparison with uptrends and ranges

To see how unusual the downtrend figures are, the table below lines up the same pattern A by market regime.

TrendNShare of trades closed in profitAverage P/LAverage lossMedian MAEProfit factor
Uptrend1,08875.6%+2.47%-7.56%-3.66%2.36
Range2,17172.0%+2.08%-7.98%-4.61%1.94
Downtrend1,90670.5%+2.04%-10.32%-5.42%1.69

Note: Past sample (N=1,088, N=2,171, N=1,906); not indicative of future results.

In pattern A, the share of trades closed in profit, average P/L and profit factor were all highest in uptrends, then ranges, then downtrends. On the other hand, the average loss (trades closed at a loss) and the median MAE (maximum adverse excursion) were the largest (most negative) in downtrends and the smallest in uptrends.

As for the average gain (trades closed in profit), the downtrend figure of +7.12% was the largest of the 3 regimes. The data show that gains were larger when the trade closed in profit, while losses were also deeper when it did not.

Patterns B and C showed the same picture: in downtrends, the share of trades closed in profit and profit factor were lower than in uptrends and ranges, and the average loss and median MAE were larger (more negative).


The "pitfalls" of downtrends

Focus on loss depth and MAE

In pattern A (no stop loss, held until RSI recovers to 50), the largest loss during downtrends reached -93.3%, much larger (more negative) than the -64.7% in uptrends and the -51.1% in ranges. Cases where RSI does not recover to 50 within 60 trading days may be more common in downtrends, and this is a phase in which unrealized losses can grow while the position is held without a stop loss.

The median MAE (the median of the largest unrealized loss during the holding period) was also -5.42% in downtrends, larger (more negative) than the -3.66% in uptrends. This means that about half of the trades experienced an unrealized loss at least this deep.

Differences in the longest losing streak (per stock)

In pattern A, the longest losing streak within a single stock was 6 in downtrends, 4 in uptrends and 7 in ranges. This shows that during downtrends there were phases in which RSI dropped below 30 repeatedly in the same stock and trades closed at a loss several times in a row.

Downtrends with a stop loss (pattern C)

In the downtrend results for pattern C (-5% stop loss plus a 10-trading-day exit), the share of trades closed in profit was 42.0%, the lowest of all 3 regimes, and the longest losing streak within a single stock was 15. A stop loss can help limit the loss on a single trade (a gap down can still push the loss beyond the stop level), but the condition tends to appear often during downtrends, so it is worth being aware of the scenario of consecutive stop-outs.

Average P/L stayed positive, but profit factor was 1.18, the lowest of all regimes.


Watch for downtrends that coincide with high volatility

For reference, in the high-volatility bucket (ATR(14)/close in the top 20%) across all market environments, pattern A had an average loss of -12.00% and a median MAE of -7.33%, more negative than the downtrend figures. This article did not measure the overlap of downtrend and high volatility itself, but periods when the two coincide may carry larger risk on both fronts.

Note: Past sample (N=1,764); not indicative of future results.


Understanding the imbalance in sample sizes

The downtrend sample for pattern A was 1,906 trades, more than the 1,088 in uptrends. This reflects the fact that the RSI-below-30 condition appears more often during downtrends. On the other hand, the regime with the largest sample of the three was ranges (2,171 trades). In pattern C, the downtrend sample was a large 3,464 trades, so the comparison appears reasonably reliable. However, note that the results may include the influence of periods when samples clustered (phases with a series of sharp declines, such as after the collapse of Lehman Brothers and during the COVID-19 crash).


Summary

In this backtest, the following tendencies were observed when buying as RSI dropped below 30 during downtrends (close below SMA200, and SMA200 lower than it was 20 trading days earlier).

  • The share of trades closed in profit, average P/L and profit factor were the lowest in downtrends of the 3 regimes (uptrend, range and downtrend)
  • The average loss (trades closed at a loss) and median MAE (maximum adverse excursion) were the largest (most negative) in downtrends
  • In the pattern without a stop loss, there were phases in which the largest loss became especially large, with the risk of a long wait before RSI returned to 50
  • Even in the pattern with a stop loss, the longest losing streak was longer than in the other regimes

Based on the historical data, the "oversold = bounce" idea can be seen as one that calls for more careful handling in downtrends, which behave differently from uptrends and ranges.

To experience price moves during downtrends in your own stocks, it helps to check the same conditions with ENTRIQ's Chart Replay. You can record and build up your test results with Strategy Tags.


Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

Q. Do RSI-below-30 buys during downtrends ever close in profit?

A. In the backtest, many trades that bought RSI below 30 during downtrends closed in profit (70.5% in pattern A). However, the average loss and median MAE were larger than in the other regimes, so it is important to examine the conditions thoroughly before building them into your own rules. Note: Past sample (N=1,906); not indicative of future results.

Q. How do I identify a downtrend?

A. This backtest defines a downtrend as "the close is below SMA200, and SMA200 is lower than it was 20 trading days earlier." The key point is to check the direction of SMA200.

Q. Does a stop loss make downtrends less of a concern?

A. Even in pattern C, which uses a -5% stop loss, the longest losing streak within a single stock was 15 during downtrends. A stop loss helps limit the loss on each trade, but in phases where the condition appears repeatedly, several consecutive stop-outs can occur. Note: Past sample (N=3,464); not indicative of future results.

Q. Can I apply these results directly to my own trading?

A. Results change when the stocks, period or timeframe change, and they are also affected by survivorship bias. Use the figures to organize your thinking, and retest the conditions on the stocks you trade.


This article is provided for informational purposes to examine and organize historical data and does not recommend any specific trade. The figures shown are past samples and do not indicate future results. All investment decisions are your own responsibility.

Test the same condition used in this article on symbols of your choice.

Backtest this condition

Reproduce this validation yourself

With ENTRIQ's chart replay, you can trade through past charts using the same rules.

Try the demo — no sign-up

No sign-up or card needed. Runs right in your browser. Start 14-day free trial →

Validate your method on past charts

The same validation in this article can be reproduced with your own method. On past charts, do the classics really work?

  • ✓ Replay past charts
  • ✓ AI feedback on your trades
  • ✓ Validate methods with statistics

No sign-up or card needed. Runs right in your browser.

Related reading

StrategyLAYER 1

Daily MACD Death Cross Shorts on US Stocks|3 Exits Compared

ENTRIQ backtest of shorting from the day after a MACD(12, 26, 9) death cross on daily charts of 100 US stocks (5–56 years each), with 3 exit patterns.

StrategyLAYER 1

Daily MACD Golden Cross Buys on US Stocks|3 Exits Compared

ENTRIQ backtest of buying after the MACD(12, 26, 9) golden cross on daily charts of 100 US stocks (5–56 years each), with figures for 3 exit patterns.

StrategyLAYER 1

Daily RSI vs Stochastics on US Stocks|Contrarian Entries

ENTRIQ backtest: RSI(14) vs slow stochastics (14, 3, 3) contrarian entries with identical exits on daily charts of 100 US stocks (5–56 years each).

StrategyLAYER 1

Daily RSI Below 30 on US Stocks|Effect of a MACD Filter

ENTRIQ backtest of 100 US stocks on daily charts (5–56 years each): RSI-below-30 buys on days with MACD(12, 26, 9) above its signal line vs no filter, 3 exits.

Try in ENTRIQ

Reproduce this validation with your own method

Replay past charts and discover your method's actual win rate.

Try the demo — no sign-up

Start 14-day free trial →